Vintage Dooney & Bourke: Know This Before You Buy a Fake

The Velvet Muzzle
Jun 3
5 min read

Let’s be honest—when you’re out thrifting, browsing estate sales, or scrolling resale sites for vintage Dooney & Bourke bags, it can be hard to tell what’s real and what’s fake. We’re not experts; however, we’ve handled a lot of vintage Dooneys through our restoration work at The Velvet Muzzle, and we’ve picked up some helpful tricks along the way.

Today, we’re sharing the key things we look for when trying to identify a fake vintage Dooney & Bourke bag. These are small details that make a big difference—and they’re all things you can check at home, no authentication service required.

💡 Prefer video? Check out our latest video where we show a side-by-side comparison of a real and a fake Vintage Dooney & Bourke Carrier Bag.

The Velvet Muzzle: Restored Preloved Vintage Luxury Bags

At The Velvet Muzzle, we specialize in restored preloved vintage luxury bags, giving each one a second chance. Some of the bags we restore become part of our personal collection, while others are offered for sale on our website: www.thevelvetmuzzle.com. Every bag we choose is treated with love and care, ensuring it’s ready for its next chapter.

Vintage Dooney & Bourke: Know This Before You Buy a Fake

This article features a comparison between a real Vintage Dooney & Bourke Carrier Bag—a piece that’s over three decades old—and a fake Vintage Dooney & Bourke Carrier Bag.

1. Feel the Texture of the Leather

Real vintage All Weather Leather has a unique texture—firm but flexible, with a slightly waxy, pebbled finish. It bends naturally and feels luxurious in your hands.

👎 Fake bags often use PVC or plastic. They feel stiff, rubbery, or overly shiny. You might even hear a plastic-y “click” when you tap them.

Run your fingers across the surface and gently flex the flap. Real leather will move and soften with age; synthetic materials tend to stay rigid, or even crack over time.

Take a sniff, too. Real leather smells like, well, leather—earthy, rich, and natural. Fakes often smell like chemicals or glue, which is a big red flag.

And don’t forget the innards. On some fake bags, you’ll find the internal structure made from cardboard instead of proper reinforcement. If you gently bend or flex the bag, it might actually sound like cardboard—a subtle but telling sign of a fake.

2. Check the Trim

Knowing the proper trim design for the specific vintage Dooney & Bourke bag you're examining is a crucial step in spotting a fake. The trim details vary by model and era, so it helps to be familiar with the authentic look before you buy.

For vintage Carrier Bags, two trim areas are especially important:

The bottom panel: Authentic Carrier Bags do not have a trim piece on the bottom. Instead, the All-Weather Leather is carried to the bottom of the bag with piped trim—a seamless, polished finish without any contrasting strips. 🧯 Red Flag: If the bottom of the bag features a contrasting leather strip or panel, usually in British Tan—this is a strong indicator the bag is fake.
The front trim panel: Authentic Carrier Bags feature a small front bottom panel of contrasting leather which matches the flap. On genuine Carrier Bags, this trim is typically in British Tan or Burnt Cedar, adding a subtle but distinctive touch. ✅ On the real bag: This front trim panel is always present and well-crafted. 🚫 On many fakes: This panel is missing altogether or poorly replicated.

This trim detail can be easy to overlook unless you know what to look for—but it’s a quick way to tell if your vintage Dooney is the real deal.

3. Examine the Duck Logo Patch

Vintage Dooney bags, like our Carrier bag, which features a signature leather patch with the classic duck and oval logo. It’s not just about having the logo—it’s about how it’s made.

🕵️‍♀️ On a real bag, the patch is embossed or raised, stitched on cleanly, and sits flush with the bag. The duck’s eye is large, and its bill rests slightly above its back—not directly on it.

❌ On fakes, the patch might be printed, peeling, or the wrong shape entirely—too round, too shiny, or even glued on.

Bonus tip: The authentic patch usually says “Dooney & Bourke All Weather Leather”, not just “Dooney & Bourke.”

4. Check the Hardware Quality

Dooney didn’t skimp on the brass. The hardware on authentic vintage bags is solid brass—it has weight, warmth, and develops a beautiful patina over time.

✅ Real brass feels hefty, tarnishes naturally, and can be cleaned and polished to shine.

❌ Fake brass is usually lightweight, chips easily, and has a dull or uneven finish.

The turn-locks, D-rings, strap hooks, and even rivets should feel substantial. It’s also important to know the correct type and style of hardware for the specific bag you’re looking at—for example, authentic vintage Dooney & Bourke Carrier Bags use D-rings to attach the crossbody strap.

If the hardware flakes or shows a mixed gold and silver tone, or if the style doesn’t match what’s expected, it’s a red flag—back away slowly.

5. Look at the Strap and Handle Attachments

Real Dooney bags are built for wear and repair. That means the strap hardware is often removable, usually via brass brads.

🛠 On genuine bags, you can remove hardware for cleaning or restoration.

🚫 Fakes often use rivets, weird square hardware, or even glue—none of which were used on the originals.

It’s not just about aesthetics; it’s about construction and craftsmanship.

Final Thoughts: Trust the Details

Authentic vintage Dooney & Bourke bags are a true testament to quality craftsmanship. The brand’s signature All Weather Leather is not only soft and pliable, but also heavy and rugged—built to last for decades without losing its luxurious feel.

When you hold a real Dooney, you’ll notice the bag has a substantial weight that speaks to its durability and premium materials.

Take a close look at the stitching—it’s always immaculate, even, and tight, with no loose threads or uneven lines. This level of precision is a hallmark of vintage Dooneys and one of the easiest ways to spot a fake.

Overall, these bags don’t just feel heavy—they feel expensive and refined, with a presence that immediately conveys quality at first touch.

We hope you enjoyed learning about some of the key things we look for when identifying a fake vintage Dooney & Bourke bag. If you’d like to explore more about vintage bag restorations or browse our collection of preloved luxury treasures, be sure to visit us at www.thevelvetmuzzle.com.

Join The Velvet Muzzle Community

If you love restored preloved vintage luxury bags, designer bag restorations and thrifted fashion, don’t forget to subscribe to our YouTube channel and follow us on social media @thevelvetmuzzle for more vintage and luxury bag transformations and restoration tips. We post new content regularly, and you won’t want to miss any of our upcoming projects!